Blog
How to Exfoliate Your Face: AHA, BHA, PHA or Enzymes, Which to Choose?
Face exfoliant: what AHAs, BHA, PHAs and enzymes do, for which skin, how often, and the signs of over-exfoliation.
Key takeaways
- AHAs (glycolic acid, lactic acid) dissolve in water and make skin more sensitive to the sun, an effect that disappears a week after you stop.
- BHA, meaning salicylic acid, mixes with sebum: it suits oily skin and clogged pores first.
- PHAs such as gluconolactone gave effects close to an AHA in twelve weeks, with less stinging.
- Enzymes are valued for their gentleness; for every family, the stronger the exfoliation, the less often you use it, with one exfoliant per evening.
In 1974, two researchers, Eugene Van Scott and Ruey Yu, published a study on alpha hydroxy acids (AHAs) in the Archives of Dermatology. They applied them to ichthyoses, conditions that make the skin dry and scaly. Half a century later, AHAs share the shelf with BHAs, PHAs and enzymes. Yet a face exfoliant is chosen less for its strength than for where it works and how often your skin can take it. Enzymes, for their part, are valued for their gentleness. Find out what each family does, for which skin, and how often.
Face exfoliant: physical or chemical, what you are really removing
Exfoliating means removing dead cells from the surface of the skin. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) distinguishes two methods in its guide to exfoliation. Physical exfoliation removes them mechanically, with a brush, a sponge or a grainy scrub. Chemical exfoliation dissolves them, with acids such as AHAs and BHAs.
On blemish-prone skin, scrubbing only makes breakouts worse, the AAD warns in its guide to acne. For dry, sensitive or acne-prone skin, it suggests a simple washcloth and a mild chemical exfoliant instead. On medium to dark skin tones, it advises avoiding strong exfoliation, chemical or physical, which can leave dark spots.
Not all chemical exfoliants are equal, though. Each family works in a different place, with its own tolerance. The right choice depends on what you are after: smoother texture, clearer pores, or gentle care for reactive skin.
AHAs: glycolic acid and lactic acid, to watch in the sun
The work of Van Scott and Yu made the exfoliating effect of AHAs known, notes a 2004 review on PHAs. The most common AHAs in cosmetics are glycolic acid and lactic acid, according to the FDA, the US agency in charge of drugs and cosmetics. Citric acid is also one of them. These acids dissolve in water. Salicylic acid, on the other hand, mixes with the sebum in pores, explains a 2015 review dedicated to salicylic acid.
The COSRX AHA 7 Whitehead Power Liquid is built on glycolic acid, stated at 7% on its product page. It is applied with a cotton pad in the evening, two to three times a week, on dull skin or uneven texture. Its product page asks you not to combine it with another exfoliant on the same evening.
AHAs have a downside, measured in studies conducted with the FDA. After four weeks of use, volunteers' sensitivity to UV-induced redness rose by 18%. UV damage to skin cells doubled on average. The effect disappeared one week after stopping the product. One of these studies, published in 2003, involved 29 volunteers who applied 10% glycolic acid to their backs six days out of seven.
18%
That is the increase, after four weeks of AHA use, in the skin's sensitivity to UV-induced redness, compared with the same cream without AHA, according to the FDA. The effect disappears one week after stopping: sunscreen should therefore accompany the whole period of use and the week after. FDA, "Alpha Hydroxy Acids".
Since 2005, the FDA has recommended a warning on the label. It advises sunscreen, protective clothing and limited sun exposure while using the product and for the week after. With an AHA, evening application and morning sunscreen therefore go together (see our article on Korean sunscreen).
BHA: salicylic acid, which goes down into the pore
On labels, the acronym BHA refers to salicylic acid. Being oil-soluble, it mixes with sebum, explains the 2015 review. It therefore concentrates in the pilosebaceous follicle, where blackheads form. It suits oily skin and clogged pores first and foremost. In Europe, the Cosmetics Regulation caps its concentration at 2% in a face product.
The authors of a 2010 review on hydroxy acids compared it with glycolic acid under sun exposure. At 2%, salicylic acid did not increase the skin's sensitivity to UV, while 10% glycolic acid did. During pregnancy, ask your doctor before using a salicylic acid product. As a precaution, the European Union revised its classification in 2018, through Regulation (EU) 2018/1480. For blackheads, our article on enlarged pores and blackheads details the full routine.
PHAs: the same family as AHAs, only gentler
PHAs, or polyhydroxy acids, are AHAs that carry several hydroxyl groups, explains the 2010 review. A hydroxyl group combines one oxygen atom and one hydrogen atom; it is what gives hydroxy acids their name. The most common is gluconolactone. Lactobionic acid is a variant of it, with an added sugar.
Their gentleness was measured in a twelve-week trial published in 2004. It compared a gluconolactone routine with a glycolic acid routine. Both reduced signs of aging to a comparable degree, measured in particular on imprints of crow's feet. The AHA did slightly better on dullness and elasticity. But stinging and burning were clearly more pronounced with the AHA, at six as at twelve weeks.
The trial was run by researchers from the American laboratory NeoStrata, a specialist in exfoliating acids. Another study, cited by the 2010 review, compared the two under UV exposure. Glycolic acid increased the number of damaged cells; gluconolactone did not.
The NOAV Night Repair Clear Pad toner pads contain gluconolactone, with panthenol and centella. They are placed on the forehead and cheeks in the evening for three to five minutes, before gently wiping the face. Their product page also lists essential oils: on reactive skin, patch test on a small area first.
Enzymes: exfoliation valued for its gentleness
Enzyme exfoliants rely on proteases, enzymes that break down proteins. The best known are papain, from papaya, and bromelain, from pineapple. They mimic desquamation, the natural shedding of dead cells, explains a 2022 Brazilian review.
Like any active ingredient, they can cause allergic reactions or irritation, its authors point out, and their activity varies with pH and temperature.
11
articles gathered in 2022 by a Brazilian review dedicated to exfoliating enzymes, valued for their gentleness. On sensitive skin, patch test on a small area first. Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology, 2022.
The Anua Rice Enzyme Brightening Cleansing Powder combines papain and protease with rice powders. You lather it in your palm with a few drops of water, massage it in, then rinse. Its product page recommends it two to four times a week, depending on how sensitive your skin is. Its ingredient list ends with tartaric acid and lactic acid, an AHA.
Which face exfoliant to choose, and how often
The following table compares families of active ingredients, not products: actual tolerance depends mostly on concentration and formula.
| Family (name in the INCI list) | What studies show | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| AHA (Glycolic Acid, Lactic Acid) | Exfoliation and smoother skin, studied since 1974 | Increased sun sensitivity, which disappears one week after stopping |
| BHA (Salicylic Acid) | Mixes with sebum and concentrates in pores | 2% maximum in a face product; medical advice during pregnancy |
| PHA (Gluconolactone, Lactobionic Acid) | Effects close to an AHA over twelve weeks, with less stinging | A patch test on a small area for reactive skin |
| Enzymes (Papain, Bromelain, Protease) | Mimic natural desquamation, according to a 2022 review | Possible allergic reactions or irritation |
Frequency depends on the skin and the method, the AAD reminds us: the stronger the exfoliation, the less often you repeat it. The product pages of the products mentioned here follow this logic. The 7% AHA is limited to two or three evenings a week, the enzyme powder to two to four times. Some very gentle PHA toner pads, however, are designed for morning and evening use.
Over-exfoliating makes skin red and irritated, the AAD warns. It advises against exfoliating skin that has cuts, open wounds or sunburn. With retinol, a prescription retinoid or benzoyl peroxide, skin can also become more sensitive and peel. So one exfoliant family per evening is better, followed by a moisturizer, which the AAD recommends applying right after. If irritation persists, stop the product and ask a pharmacist or dermatologist for advice.
At Fiveaven, we recommend choosing an exfoliant for what you want it to do, not for its strength. An AHA suits texture and radiance, a BHA suits clogged pores. A PHA is kind to skin that reacts quickly, and an enzyme lends itself to a rinse-off product. Then adjust the frequency to how your skin reacts, with one exfoliant at a time. If you are unsure about your skin type, our Skin Diagnosis pins it down in a few questions. Our exfoliants are also gathered on a single page.
Your questions
Can you exfoliate your face every day?
Rarely with an acid: the product pages of our AHA and BHA products often limit them to two or three evenings a week. Some very gentle PHA toner pads are designed for daily use, according to their product page. In any case, the stronger the exfoliation, the less often you repeat it, according to the AAD.
Which exfoliant should you choose for sensitive skin?
A mild chemical exfoliant rather than a scrub: the AAD suggests a washcloth and a light chemical exfoliant for sensitive skin. In the 2004 trial, PHAs stung much less than glycolic acid. Patch test on a small area first, then space out applications.
Can you use an AHA in summer?
Yes, as long as you protect your skin from the sun. The FDA advises sunscreen, protective clothing and limited exposure, during use and for the week after. Apply the AHA in the evening, as the product pages of our products recommend.
Can you combine AHA and BHA?
Yes, in the same formula: some toners combine glycolic acid and salicylic acid. Layering two exfoliants on the same evening is another matter, and the product pages of our products advise against it.
Sources
- Van Scott E. J., Yu R. J., "Control of keratinization with alpha-hydroxy acids and related compounds. I. Topical treatment of ichthyotic disorders", Archives of Dermatology, 1974.
- Grimes P. E. et al., "The use of polyhydroxy acids (PHAs) in photoaged skin", Cutis, 2004.
- Edison B. L. et al., "A polyhydroxy acid skin care regimen provides antiaging effects comparable to an alpha-hydroxyacid regimen", Cutis, 2004.
- Kaidbey K. et al., "Topical glycolic acid enhances photodamage by ultraviolet light", Photodermatology, Photoimmunology & Photomedicine, 2003.
- Kornhauser A. et al., "Applications of hydroxy acids: classification, mechanisms, and photoactivity", Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology, 2010.
- Arif T., "Salicylic acid as a peeling agent: a comprehensive review", Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology, 2015.
- Trevisol T. C. et al., "An overview of the use of proteolytic enzymes as exfoliating agents", Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology, 2022.
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration, "Alpha Hydroxy Acids".
- American Academy of Dermatology, "How to safely exfoliate at home".
- American Academy of Dermatology, "How to treat different types of acne".
- European Parliament and Council, "Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products", consolidated version of September 1, 2025, Annex III, entry 98.
- European Commission, "Commission Regulation (EU) 2018/1480 of October 4, 2018" (harmonized classification of substances), Official Journal of the European Union, 2018.



