Blog

Retinal or retinol: which to choose, and how to start without irritation?

Retinal vs retinol: a side-by-side comparison, who each one suits, how to start without irritation and 3 common myths about retinol.

Published

7 min read

Key takeaways

  • Retinal is one step ahead of retinol: it is more active, while still fairly well tolerated.
  • Since November 1, 2025, a face product placed on the European market contains no more than 0.3% retinol equivalent.
  • Start with two evenings a week, and increase only if your skin does not sting, peel or feel tight.
  • Peeling skin is not a sign the product is working: it is a side effect of the first few weeks.
Rétinal ou rétinol : lequel choisir, et comment débuter sans irriter ?

Retinal, or retinaldehyde, and retinol belong to the same family: vitamin A. The skin converts retinol into retinal, then retinal into retinoic acid, the form that acts inside the cells. Retinal is therefore one step ahead: it is more active, while remaining fairly well tolerated. Retinol, slower, is mildly irritating and remains the gentlest way in: the right choice depends mostly on your skin and the pace you give it.

Retinal vs retinol: side by side, criterion by criterion

Retinal is the intermediate between retinol and retinoic acid, as a 2006 review on retinoids and skin aging explains. Retinoic acid, or tretinoin, is a prescription drug, about 20 times more potent than retinol according to this review. The comparison below looks at the actives alone: in a real product, the dose and frequency matter as much as the name on the bottle.

Criterion Retinal Retinol
Steps before the active form One Two
Activity in studies Ahead of retinol, just behind retinoic acid Real, but gentle
Tolerance Fairly well tolerated Mildly irritating
Name on the ingredient list Retinal Retinol
Limit in Europe Not covered by the European retinol cap 0.3% maximum in a face product
When Evening Evening
Typical profile Skin already used to a retinoid A first retinoid

This order comes from a 1994 Swiss study carried out on human skin: retinal comes in just behind retinoic acid, ahead of retinol. A 2006 review on retinoids in cosmetics points the same way: retinol stands out for its gentleness, while retinal, fairly well tolerated, appears as the most effective of the cosmetic retinoids.

0.3%

This is the maximum retinol content of a face product placed on the European market since November 1, 2025.

This cap is detailed by the consumer association Test-Achats. It adopts the threshold considered safe for face creams by the European Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety in 2016, in an opinion on retinol and two of its derivatives. Higher-strength products already on shelves may be sold until May 1, 2027.

Who is retinal for, who is retinol for?

  • A first retinoid: low-strength retinol remains the simplest start. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) recommends the least intense formula possible, every other evening, then increasing gradually.
  • Skin that already tolerates retinol: retinal is the logical next step. For the first few weeks, go back to a spaced-out pace.
  • Sensitive skin or skin that flushes quickly: the AAD advises against retinoids on very red or inflamed skin. Bakuchiol, a plant molecule that is not a retinoid, is another option. In a 2019 American study, it reduced wrinkles and dark spots as much as retinol over twelve weeks, with less stinging.
  • Medium to dark skin tones: irritation can leave brown marks, the AAD warns, and it advises starting slowly and hydrating.
  • The eye area: some products are formulated for this zone, for example the Numbuzin No.9 NAD+ Retinol eye cream, which combines retinol, niacinamide and peptides. The product page of the KSECRET retinal serum, on the other hand, asks you to avoid the eye area.

Starting without irritation, week by week

Product pages recommend starting with two or three evenings a week, and the AAD recommends increasing gradually. Move to the next step only if your skin does not sting, peel or feel tight.

  1. Two evenings a week

    Space them out, Monday and Thursday for example. Apply the product in a thin layer on clean, fully dry skin, away from the eyelids.

    2 weeks

  2. Three evenings a week

    If you feel any discomfort, go back to two evenings for a week.

    2 weeks

  3. Every other evening

    Follow the product each time with a generous layer of moisturizer.

    4 weeks

  4. Every evening, if your skin keeps up

    The studies cited here measure effects after one to three months: that is the time to allow before judging a product.

    After that

During these first weeks, set exfoliants aside (AHA and BHA acids, scrubs): the AAD warns that exfoliating while using retinol can worsen dryness, or even cause breakouts. In the morning, sunscreen completes the routine, because retinoids can make skin more sensitive to the sun (see our article on Korean sunscreen). The full order of steps is in our guide to the morning and evening skincare routine.

Three myths about retinol

"Retinol thins the skin"

False

Applied to the skin, retinol thickens the epidermis, the outer layer of the skin, just like retinoic acid, according to the review on skin aging. The 1994 Swiss study measured the same effect with retinal, more marked at a higher dose.

"If your skin peels, the product is working"

False

Redness, burning and peeling make up the "retinoid reaction", a side effect of the first weeks, rarer with retinol and retinal than with tretinoin. In the trials gathered by the same review, retinal worked on wrinkles as well as retinoic acid, while causing less irritation.

"Retinol and niacinamide don't mix"

False

In a 2006 American study, a cream with niacinamide, panthenol and vitamin E made the first weeks of tretinoin easier. The KSECRET Seoul 1988 serum in fact combines retinal and niacinamide. A cream with niacinamide and panthenol, such as the MIDHA Rice Cream, can follow it.

Your questions

Which retinol to choose as a beginner?

A low-strength retinol: the AAD recommends the least intense formula possible, every other evening, then increasing gradually. On the label, the position of "Retinol" or "Retinal" in the list does not tell you its dose: below 1%, ingredients may be listed in any order, the French National Consumer Institute points out. If you are unsure about the state of your skin, the Skin Diagnosis assesses it in a few questions.

How to start retinol without irritating your skin?

Start with two evenings a week, in a thin layer on clean, fully dry skin, and move to the next step only if your skin does not sting, peel or feel tight. If you feel discomfort, go back to the previous pace, hydrate more and set exfoliants aside; if irritation persists, stop the product and ask a pharmacist or dermatologist for advice.

What is the difference between retinal and retinol, and which is more effective?

Retinal is one step ahead: the skin converts retinol into retinal, then retinal into retinoic acid, the form that acts inside the cells. Closer to this active form, it comes ahead of retinol in the 1994 study as in the review on retinoids in cosmetics, while remaining fairly well tolerated; results also depend on the dose, the formula and your consistency.

What should you not mix retinol with?

With exfoliants (AHA and BHA acids, scrubs), at least during the first weeks: the AAD warns that exfoliating while using retinol can worsen dryness, or even cause breakouts. Niacinamide, on the other hand, can go with it: in the 2006 American study, a cream with niacinamide, panthenol and vitamin E made the first weeks of tretinoin easier.

Can you use retinol or retinal during pregnancy or breastfeeding?

The AAD states that retinoids should not be used during pregnancy, and in France, retinoid medicines applied to the skin have been contraindicated since 2018 for women who are pregnant or planning a pregnancy, according to the French medicines agency. For a cosmetic with retinol or retinal, ask your doctor or pharmacist for advice if you are pregnant, breastfeeding or planning a pregnancy.

Sources

Keep reading